SPORTSPARK 250 MAIN STREET ENTER ON SOUTH SIDE OF BUILDING ACROSS FROM GRADUATE HOTEL
FRIDAY 7 A.M. TO 4 P.M. SATURDAY 8 A.M. TO 5 P.M SUNDAY 8 A.M. TO 4 P.M.
IF YOU DO NOT VOTE THERE MAY NOT BE FUTURE EARLY VOTING ON ROOSEVELT ISLAND
FRIDAY, JUNE 18, 2021
The
393rd Edition
The 1887
ELDRIDGE STREET
SYNAGOGUE
FROM:
DAYTONIAN IN MANHATTAN
When brothers Peter and Francis Herter founded the architectural firm of Herter Brothers (not to be confused with the interior decorating and furniture firm of the same name), they had already been well established in their native Germany. Upon his arrival in New York in 1884 The New York Times called Peter “the richest builder on the banks of the Rhine.”
The Herters set about designing tenement buildings for the waves of immigrants settling on the Lower East Side. A major departure came when they were awarded the commission to design a grand synagogue at No. 12 Eldridge Street.
By the middle of the 1880s, thousands of poor Eastern European Jews were flocking to the neighborhood. The former Head Rabbi of St. Petersburg was one of the founders of the Congregation K’hal Adath Jeshuran and in 1886 he helped plan for a synagogue in which this new population could worship.
In addition to providing a house of worship, the leaders wanted to show the rest of the city that the oft-maligned Jews of the Lower East Side, too, could produce something monumental and beautiful; something in line with the new St. Patrick’s Cathedral or the imposing Gothic churches of Fifth Avenue.
Historians Henry Stolzman and Daniel Stolzman would later point out “The construction of the Eldridge Strreet Synagogue signaled – both to non-Jews, and to the German Jews who were embarrassed by the poverty and ‘Old World’ manner of the new immigrants—that Eastern European Jews, like their predecessors, could also thrive in America.”
Opened just before the High Holy Days in 1887, the synagogue was a show-stopper. The Herters free-handedly melded Gothic, Moorish and Romanesque styles – four horseshoe-arched entrances were reflected by a gallery of similar windows directly above. A mammoth Gothic Rose window dominated the façade and a series of minaret-like towers rose above the roofline.
The highly-carved oak lecture is fitted with a brass handrail — photo eldridgestreet.org
Inside the space soared 70 feet upwards to colorful stenciled ceilings. The poor congregants, accustomed to dingy tenements and sweatshops, were surrounded by sumptuous brass lighting fixtures, 68 stained glass windows and carved wood. The velvet-lined ark, which could hold 24 Torah scrolls, was constructed in Italy from solid walnut and inlaid with mosaics.
The barrel-vaulted sanctuary with it brass main chandelier holding 75 bulbs — photo archpaper.com
The officers of the congregation established rules of decorum and ushers were appointed to enforce them. Upon signing the contract for the sale of seats, the congregants acknowledged that they “must adhere strickly to the rules for maintaining peace and order for the service.” Fines were levied for those interrupting the service by loud talking, late arrival, spitting on the floor and “unclean language.”
In order to enforce the spitting rule, dozens of spittoons were scattered about.
Eight months after its opening, the synagogue was the scene of an impressive memorial service for the German Emperor Frederick III. The temple was filled with mourners and the service was conducted in both English and German as Jews, decades away from the Holocaust, grieved the Emperor’s passing.
The synagogue was used not only as a place of worship, but it anchored the Jewish immigrant community – providing food for the poor, small financial loans, care for the sick, and information on finding employment or housing. Turn of the century Jews, however, were constantly faced with discrimination.
At a meeting in the synagogue on April 22, 1900 intended to protest immorality and vice in the neighborhood, visiting speaker Professor Adler said “I was talking with the Chief of Police recently and he whispered this in my ear: ‘Do you know who is responsible for the bad moral condition of the city? It’s just you Jews.’”
Through it all the Eldridge Street Synagogue thrived. On Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur it was necessary to post police on the street to control the throngs who flocked to the temple. By the 1920s the congregation was composed of over 300 families.
The vice and crime in the neighborhood’s that was so strongly derided by the congregation leaders in 1900 continued into the 20th Century. In 1930 thieves broke into the cellar of the synagogue, making off with antique relics and ceremonial silver items valued at over $2,000.
By the middle of the century, however, the synagogue fell on hard times. The Jewish population of the Lower East Side shrank as young members moved away to more affluent neighborhoods and the elderly died. By the late 1950s the beautiful sanctuary was sealed off and congregants conducted services in the basement.
The main synagogue sat unused for 24 years and, with no maintenance, the hand-stenciled walls and ceilings flaked and water seeped into the plaster. The degraded rear rose window was be replaced with glass blocks, rotting interior staircases were no longer safe to use, and pigeons roosted in the balconies.
The remarkable, restored trompe d oeil murals of cloth hangings can be seen on either side of the ark — photo eldridgestreet.org
The not-for-profit Eldridge Street Project was formed to save the structure. A non-sectarian group, it initiated a 20-year, $18.5 million restoration. With no vintage photographs to document what the rear rose window looked like, a design by Kiki Smith and architect Deborah Gans was chosen to replace the glass block patchwork. The designers drew on the star motif of the stenciled walls and ceilings to create an artwork of spiraling stars.
The replacement rose window by Kiki Smith and Deborah Gans — photo eldridgestreet.org
When it was re-opened in 2007, the Eldridge Street Synagogue began a new dual life as a house of worship and a museum. The Museum at Eldridge Street offers tours, concerts, lectures, and school programs.
The synagogue, now restored to its former glory, was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1996.
VOTING IN RUSSIA I AM WORKING EARLY VOTING AND WILL BE BACK NEXT WEEK WITH THE DAILY WINNERS NAMES.
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff All image are copyrighted (c)
A DAYTONIAN IN MANHATTAN
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
ENTER ON SOUTH SIDE OF BUILDING ACROSS FROM GRADUATE HOTEL
THURSDAY 10 A.M. TO 8 P.M. FRIDAY 7 A.M. TO 4 P.M. SATURDAY 8 A.M. TO 5 P.M SUNDAY 8 A.M. TO 4 P.M.
IF YOU DO NOT VOTE THERE MAY NOT BE FUTURE EARLY VOTING ON ROOSEVELT ISLAND
THURSDAY, JUNE 17, 2021
The
392nd Edition
A STATUE OF LIBERTY
REPLICA IS COMING
FROM PARIS TO THE U.S.
from UNTAPPED NEW YORK
One of our favorite fun facts is that there are replicas of the Statue of Liberty in both New York City and in Paris. We’ve just gotten word that one of the replicas in Paris is making its way over to New York City for July 4th to be inaugurated on Ellis Island! It will then travel to Washington D.C. to be on display at the French Ambassador’s Residence for Bastille Day. The effort to bring “Lady Liberty’s Little Sister” to visit the U.S. is part of a 135th anniversary celebration of the Statue of Liberty crossing the Atlantic Ocean (in pieces) and is a partnership effort between the Embassy of France in the U.S., the Conservatoire national des arts et métiers (Cnam) and the CMA CGM Group, a shipping logistics company.
The original plaster sculpture, which sculptor Auguste Bartholdi made in his Paris studio, was bequeathed to the Musée des Arts et Métiers (Museum of Arts and Crafts) in the Marais district of Paris by his widow in 1907. In 2005, the French art dealer, Guillaume Duhamel, rediscovered the sculpture while accompanying his son’s elementary school class on a visit there. He convinced the museum to let him create 12 casts from the plaster original (the maximum allowed under French law) using the lost-wax method and the museum would get to keep the first cast. It’s been on display at the museum for the last decade.
The statue was taken down from the museum on June 7, 2021 and put into a plexiglass case custom-designed for the voyage. It will then be taken to the port city of Le Havre, where it will board the CMA CGM TOSCA on June 20th headed for New York in a branded shipping container.
According to a press release from the Embassy of France in the U.S., the Conservatoire national des arts et métiers (Cnam) and the CMA CGM Group, “The arrival of the new Lady Liberty will celebrate the most central value of the French-American partnership: freedom. The technological, artistic, and logistical challenges that had to be overcome to bring this new statue to America tell a modern tale of successful international cooperation.”
In celebration, the French Embassy will be hosting a contest on Instagram (@franceintheus) for participants to win LEGO® Architecture Statue of Liberty, a France-Amerique magazine subscription, an Albertine Books membership and more. Starting June 20th, the voyage of Statue of Liberty’s “Little Sister” can be viewed live on the CMA CGM website.
The statue is scheduled to arrive in New York by July 1st, when a ceremony will take place on Ellis Island to inaugurate the statue. It will be on display on the island until July 5th after which it will be transported to Washington D.C.. by CEVA Logistics.
You can also see this statue with your tickets to our tour of the abandoned hospitals of Ellis Island, with tickets still available for the July 3 and 4:
DUE TO THE FACT THAT I AM WORKING CRAZY HOURS I CANNOT LIST THE WINNERS DAILY!! AFTER THE ELECTION THE WINNERS WILL BE POSTED
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff All image are copyrighted (c)
Sources UNTAPPED NEW YORK (C)
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
Countless people have lived and many have died on our Island. But how about a notorious Nazi spy? There’s a thriller. So lean back and enjoy a tale of spies, espionage, a femme fatale, a hero and the FBI, a tale that ends on our Island – the story of Frederick “Fritz” Joubert Duquesne.
The Duquesne Spy Ring is the largest espionage case in the United States history that ended in convictions. The German agents who made up the Duquesne Ring were placed in key jobs in the United States to get information that could be used in the event of war and to carry out acts of sabotage. After a lengthy investigation by the FBI, 14 members of a German espionage network headed by Duquesne were convicted (19 others had pleaded guilty) on December 13, 1941, just days after Germany declared war on the US.
The Spy Leader: Frederick “Fritz” Joubert Duquesne (1877–1956) was a South African Boer and German soldier, big-game hunter, journalist, and spy.
Captain Frederick Duquesne ca 1900 https://roughdiplomacy.com/convicted-members-of-duquesne-spy-ring/
Duquesne fought for the Boers in the Second Boer War and was a German secret agent during both World Wars. He led spy rings and carried out sabotage missions in South Africa, Great Britain, Central and South America, and the United States. He went by many aliases, fictionalized his identity and background on multiple occasions, and operated as a con man. He was also adviser on big game hunting to President Theodore Roosevelt, a publicist in the movie business, a journalist, a fictional Australian war hero, and head of the New Food Society in New York.
After a half century of this speckled career, in spring 1934, Duquesne became an intelligence officer for the Order of 76, an American pro-Nazi organization. Admiral Wilhelm Canaris, head of Germany’s military intelligence, knew Duquesne from WW I, and instructed his new chief of U.S. operations, Col. Nikolaus Ritter, to contact him. Ritter had been friends with Duquesne and the two spies reconnected in New York in December 1937. Ritter employed several other successful agents across the US, most notably Herman Lang, who delivered blueprints for the highly secret Norden bombsight. He also recruited William Sebold and sent him to New York to set up a shortwave radio-transmitting station to establish contact with the German shortwave station abroad. Sebold was instructed to use the code name TRAMP and to contact a fellow agent, Fritz Duquesne. Dequesne soon headed a large spy network in the US. Its job was to find holes in American military forces and preparedness before the US entered the war and to find ways to destabilize the country and its morale. The information that members of the ring passed forward supported acts of domestic terrorism and sabotage as well as industrial and military espionage. Working from a phony business office at 120 Wall St., methods were often crude but effective: Duquesne would contact defense companies such as Grumman Aircraft Engineering, requesting photos and plans of its developing technology for “lectures” he was giving. Astonishingly, the material would be sent with “warm regards.” From his hands, it would pass to Nazi eyes. One of his agents opened a restaurant and used his position to get information from his customers; another worked on an airline so that he could report Allied ships that were crossing the Atlantic Ocean; others worked as delivery people as a cover for carrying secret messages.
Duquesne’s luck finally ran out in 1941 when he was arrested by the FBI as the leader of the biggest spy network in US history after extensive surveillance of his group’s activities. On June 28, 250 agents pulled spies from ships, bars and beds. Of the 33 charged, 16 pleaded guilty, while the others went to trial and were convicted. Duquesne and Lang got hit hardest, with 18-year sentences each. The Hero: William G. Sebold, who had been blackmailed into becoming a spy for Germany, became a double agent and helped the FBI gather evidence.
Agent William Sebold (pictured with his wife Ellen). (Courtesy of Camerer)
Sebold, a German immigrant, was a naturalized American citizen when he returned to Germany to visit his mother in 1939. The Nazis, impressed with a low-level job Sebold once held in the aircraft industry, were determined to put a spymaster in place in Manhattan. Nikolaus Ritter needed a man in place to receive contraband documents and to pass along information gleaned by fifth column spies floating around Manhattan beer halls and docks. Sebold was coerced into the position — but before he even left Germany, he contacted the US Consulate in Cologne, informing it of the traitorous role he was being forced to assume. FBI agents met Sebold when his ship, the Washington, docked at Pier 59 on Feb. 8, 1940, and escorted him to headquarters.
There he repeated his incredible tale of being trained as a spymaster and provided the names of spies already at work. His story was relayed directly to FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover, who in turn informed President Franklin D. Roosevelt.
For nearly two years, the FBI ran a shortwave radio station in New York for the ring. They learned what information Germany was sending its spies in the US and controlled what was sent to Germany. After Sebold set up his own dummy office in Times Square, he stumbled on another ring operating out of New York. Two spies, a butcher and baker employed by the cruise ship Manhattan, functioned as couriers between Berlin and New York. Another confederate, Paul Fehse, was in charge of the marine division. He and an associate who worked the Brooklyn boat basin wandered the docks picking up information on shipping movements to feed U-boats their targets. (A recent book by Rhodri Jeffreys-Jones, THE NAZI SPY RING IN AMERICA, Hitler’s Agents, the FBI, and the Case That Stirred the Nation, Georgetown University Press, 2020, looks in depth at all of this.) I promised you a femme fatale: Enter Lilly Stein.
A beautiful young Austrian, a Jewish immigrant, Lilly in the early 1930s decided like so many other starving young European women to become a prostitute. But Lilly became a “high-class” whore and set her sights on bigwigs across Europe. Soon she was wealthy herself, entertaining men from Austria to Paris. Then one day in 1938 she was contacted by the Gestapo and drafted into service. Now Lilly would be a spy for them, acting as a courier. But Lilly always struggled to be the best and threw herself into spycraft, eventually becoming a capable spy herself – in the bedroom. The head of FBI operations in New York worried that Sebold had “an honesty complex” that might botch things up, but he proved immensely skilled and unflinching in the field — particularly when he came up against femme fatale Lilly Stein, who tried to seduce him. Always sexually ready — one FBI agent described her as a “good-looking nymphomaniac” — her job was to prowl nightclubs looking for men who would pillow-talk about war developments or deals in industry and finance. She made “advances” on Sebold during one of their late-night meetings, though he refused. When she was arrested with the rest of the gang, it was said that she propositioned a federal agent.
Lace, edited by Noah Sarlat, 1964, Lancer Books. The first chapter tells Lilly Stein’s story. Photos of Lilly Stein, https://roughdiplomacy.com/convicted-members-of-duquesne-spy-ring/
The end
The 64-year-old Duquesne did not escape this time. He was sentenced to 18 years in prison, with a 2-year concurrent sentence and $2,000 fine for violation of the Foreign Agents Registration Act. He began his sentence in Leavenworth Federal Penitentiary in Kansas, along with Hermann Lang. In 1945, Duquesne was transferred to the Medical Center for Federal Prisoners in Springfield, Missouri, due to his failing physical and mental health. In 1954, he was released owing to ill health, having served 14 years. His last known lecture was in 1954 at the Adventurers’ Club of New York, titled “My Life – in and out of Prison”.
Stein went to prison for 12 years. When last heard from, she was working at a luxury resort near Strasbourg, France.
Sebold’s own end was much sadder. He entered an early version of the witness protection program, moving to California and taking work at the Benicia Arsenal. But ill health plagued him, and he had trouble keeping a job. For a time he tried to make a go of it as a chicken farmer. Then paranoia set in — and it wasn’t entirely unfounded. From time to time he would receive word from family back in Germany that Nazis still had him in their sites for reprisal. Impoverished and delusional, he was committed to Napa State Hospital in 1965. Diagnosed with manic-depression, he died there of a heart attack five years later at 70.
Oh yes, Welfare Island. Fritz Duquesne died at City Hospital on Welfare Island, in New York City on 24 May 1956 at the age of 78 years. OK, just one spy. If I’ve misled you, apologies. But he did die here. And it was a pretty good story.
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
ENTER ON SOUTH SIDE OF BUILDING ACROSS FROM GRADUATE HOTEL
TUESDAY, WEDNESDAY,THURSDAY 10 A.M. TO 8 P.M. FRIDAY 7 A.M. TO 4 P.M. SATURDAY 8 A.M. TO 5 P.M SUNDAY 8 A.M. TO 4 P.M.
IF YOU DO NOT VOTE THERE MAY NOT BE FUTURE EARLY VOTING ON
ROOSEVELT ISLAND.
TUESDAY, JUNE 15, 2021
The
390th Edition
From the Archives
MABEL PUGH ARTIST
FROM THE SMITHSONIAN AMERICAN ART MUSEUM
Mabel Pugh, Twilight Snow, n.d., linoleum cut on paper, Smithsonian American Art Museum, Transfer from the North Carolina Museum of Art (Gift of the artist, 1977), 2020.4.5
Mabel Pugh (1891-1986)
FROM GALLERY C, RALEIGH, NC
Mabel Pugh was a native of Morrisville, North Carolina. Mrs. Ruth Huntington Moore encouraged Pugh to study art at Peace Junior College in Raleigh. Mable Pugh went on to study at the Art Students’ League in New York, then in Philadelphia at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts. Mabel Pugh won the Cresson Traveling Scholarship in 1919 while at the Academy. This was her first opportunity to travel and sketch in Europe and she was there for four months.
When she returned from Europe, Pugh settled in New York. She began to work as a professional artist. Success followed soon. Her block prints began appearing on the covers of popular novels. Her illustrations were published in those same books. Then her paintings started to receive recognition at exhibitions. Publishers quickly recognized Mabel Pugh’s talent. Her illustrations were used in many magazines such as McCall’s, Ladies’ Home Journal, The Forum and The Survey Graphic. The artist won numerous exhibition awards at various venues including the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts in 1920, the National Association of Women Painters and Sculptors in 1934. Mabel Pugh’s painting “My Mother” was included in the first New York World’s Fair. She wrote and illustrated “Little Carolina Bluebonnet” which was first published in 1933 by Crowell.
In 1926 Pugh exhibited a series of wood block prints in the International Print Makers Exhibition at Los Angeles. This series, done from sketches she made in Europe, received accolades from as far away as Australia. The director of the Museum of Fine Arts in Houston, Texas, purchased a piece and later hosted an exhibit of the artist’s prints at that museum. In 1931 the artist was recognized as a charter member of the North Carolina Association of Professional Artists, though already well established in New York City as a printmaker, painter and illustrator.
When her original art instructor Mrs. Moore passed away, Peace College in Raleigh asked Mabel to return and become head of the Art Department; she accepted the offer and moved back to her hometown of Morrisville in 1938. Pugh continued to publish her illustrations and retired from Peace College in 1960, so she could devote all of her energy to her creative endeavors.
Mabel Pugh, Laundry Workers, ca. 1936-1960, monoprint, Smithsonian American Art Museum, Transfer from the North Carolina Museum of Art (Gift of the artist, 1977), 2020.4.2
Mabel Pugh, At the Tubs, ca. 1936-1960, lithograph, Smithsonian American Art Museum, Transfer from the North Carolina Museum of Art (Gift of the artist, 1977), 2020.4.1
Mabel Pugh, Little Church Around the Corner, ca. 1926-1936, linoleum cut on paper, Smithsonian American Art Museum, Gift of Martin Diamond, 1992.110
Mabel Pugh, John Curry and Peter Newell, 1954, lithograph, Smithsonian American Art Museum, Transfer from the North Carolina Museum of Art (Gift of the artist, 1977), 2020.4.6
Portrait in Red and Black Silk Dress, oil on canvas, 26 x 19 inches Gallery C, Raleigh, NC
Portrait of Ellen Stone Scott, oil on canvas, 1926, 36 x 40 inches
ALEXIS VILLEFANE GUESSED THE STICKER LEADING TO THE EARLY VOTING POLL SITE AT SPORTSPARK
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff Sources
SMITHSONIAN AMERICAN ART MUSEUM
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
I’m often asked what my favorite weird/obscure fact about New York City was. Ironically, as the founder of Untapped New York, this question frequently proves difficult because there are just so many amazing things about this city. So I went back into my memory archives, thinking what about New York City impelled me to create Untapped New York. The pneumatic tube mail system is top on that list.
The first pneumatic tube mail system was installed in Philadelphia (sorry New York) in 1893. New York City’s came in 1897. Each tube could carry between 400 and 600 letters and traveled at 30-35 miles per hour. In its full glory, the pneumatic tubes covered a 27-mile route, connecting 23 post offices. This network stretched up Manhattan’s east and west sides, from Bowling Green and Wall Street, all the way north to Manhattanville and East Harlem.
Anecdotal stories indicate that the system may have extended into the Bronx, with sandwich subs reportedly being delivered via pneumatic tubes from a renown subway shop in the Bronx to downtown postal stations. Maps at the National Postal Museum show proposed extensions to the Bronx and other areas within Manhattan, many which were never completed. The system even crossed boroughs into Brooklyn (using the Brooklyn Bridge), taking four minutes to take letters from Church Street near City Hall to the General Post Office in Brooklyn (now Cadman Plaza).
The system, which was located 4 to 6 feet below the city streets, was created and owned by private companies, to which the city paid rent and labor. According to The Smithsonian National Postal Museum, “Installation of the tubes was problematic, with previously laid pipes for sewage and gas limiting the size and thus the amount and kind of mail a pneumatic tube could carry. Water table levels also presented difficulties. Later, the New York City system was purchased and operated by the U.S. Postal Service. Using power from old-school electric motors, made by the likes of General Electric and Westinghouse, air pressure was created by rotary blowers and air compressors. Each canister was labeled on the outside with its destination, but all the tubes had to come out at each station. So if a canister was destined for another station, it would be sent back again into the tubes and on its way.
To feed my growing obsession with pneumatic mail, I went to Washington D.C.’s Smithsonian National Postal Museum where I met with Manda Kowalczyk an Accessions Officer at the Museum. She pulled all the items in the Postal Museum that are connected to the pneumatic tube mail systems in America. One of them you can see on a regular visit to the museum is the pneumatic tube mail canister which is on exhibit. This 24 inch long, 8 inch wide metal canister could carry somewhere between 400 and 600 letters. And, it could have definitely fit a small black cat.
Pneumatic Tube Mail system map of New York City from November 1937. Photo courtesy National Postal Museum, Smithsonian Institution
The Postal Museum also has several maps of the New York City pneumatic tube system, mostly from the 1930s and 40s. A 1947 map has some fun facts, including the time it took to send mail between the General Post Office and other stations, the number of canisters that went through the system daily (95,000), the pressure needed (3 to 8 lbs per inch), and the speed (5 tube carriers per minute and 30 mph). That year there were 26.969 miles of 2 way pneumatic tubes tubes. It even has the hours of operation: Weekdays from 5 AM to 10 PM, Saturday from 5 AM to 10 AM, and no service on Sundays and legal holidays. I love the thought of mail getting shot underground at 5 AM to arrive just time for the beginning of the work day.
A message you’d get from the Postmaster if your mail was damaged in the pneumatic tube. Photo courtesy National Postal Museum, Smithsonian Institution According to Kate Ascher, author of The Works, “The high operating costs of the pneumatic system ultimately proved its downfall. By 1918, the federal government considered the annual rental payments ($17,000 per mile per annum) made by the post office to be ‘exorbitant’ and endorsed a new alternative with greater capacity–the automobile–as the delivery method of choice.” In New York City, a successful lobby by contractors led to the reinstatement of pneumatic mail service in 1922. A complete stop didn’t happen until 1953. Paris’ system, which covered 269 miles, continued for an additional 34 years (but was more limited in what it could carry–the pipes were only 2 inches diameter).
Pneumatic tube mail remnants inside the Old Chelsea Post Office And what’s left of the pneumatic tubes? Not much, if at all. The location of the tubes within a city’s underbelly basically guaranteed its destruction once no longer in use. The only known remaining remnant of the pneumatic tube mail system is in the Old Chelsea Post Office at 217 W 18th Street, where tubes come through a wall in the basement. They sit at the end of a forgotten brick-lined hallway filled with office supplies. Kate Ascher also notes that there was a time when remnants of the pneumatic tubes were still being found, but not often any longer. Some additional fun facts about the pneumatic tube mail system: According to this incredible article by Robert A. Cohen, the first cylinder tube to travel through the New York City system contained “a Bible, a flag and a copy of the Constitution. The second contained an imitation peach in honor of Senator Chauncy Depew (He was fondly known as “The Peach”). A third carrier had a black cat in it, for reasons unknown.” It had set hours of operation: 5am to 10pm on weekdays, and 5am to 10am on Saturdays The size of the carriers in New York City was 24 inches long, 8 inches across 95,000 letters were moved daily, about 1/3 of all first class letters It took 4 minutes to get from the General Post Office (now Moynihan Train Hall) to Grand Central using a tranverse tube that cut across Manhattan It took between 15 and 20 minutes for mail to get from Herald Square to Manhattanville and East Harlem It took 11 minutes to get from the General Post Office to the Planetarium Post Office, near the Museum of Natural History
PHOTO OF THE WEEK
EARLY VOTING ON ROOSEVELT ISLAND AT SPORTSPARKS VOTE TODAY FROM 7 A.M. TO 4 P.M. (I WILL BE THERE TO GREET OUR LOYAL READERS!)
VINTAGE MAP OF NEW YORK ED LITCHER GOT IT!WE ARE WORKING EARLY VOTING SO WE WILL BE A LITTLE DISCOMBOBULATED THIS WEEK!
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Deborah Dorff All image are copyrighted (c)
UNTAPPED NEW YORK
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
Georgette Sinclair’s art training started in her childhood when she attended the Public School of Art in Romania where she took drawing and painting classes.
After Ms. Sinclair immigrated to the United States, she started a new life as an American citizen while attending school at night. She obtained a Master of Science and a Doctoral degree in Audiology, which adds to her Master degree in Special Psychology and Pedagogy already earned back in Romania from Cluj-Napoca University.
In New York, she attended the Art Student League of NYC, studying under Richard Pionk and John Foote, in addition to attending workshops at Woodstock School of Art and the Hudson River Valley Art School. She also studied with master pastelist, Elizabeth Mowry, at various workshops in France in the Artist’s Retreat Program.
Ms. Sinclair works mostly in pastels and oils and is fascinated by the beauty of nature. She finds poetry in ordinary scenes and her landscapes express a mood and speak to everyone by freezing a moment before it is gone forever. In her vision, expression of mood is the response to a fragment in time. She delights in painting outdoors but is also fascinated by peeking in and out of the windows which are the subject of some of her paintings. She travels extensively and her trips, a great source of inspiration, have a big impact on her work.
Ms. Sinclair has been a member of the Salmagundi Club and Pen & Brush, Inc, NYC since 2001 and RIVAA (Roosevelt Island Visual Art Association, NYC) since 2000.
I am working early voting this week, so forgive me if I miss some names. KATZ, ED LITCHER, MITCH HAMMER GOT IT
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Deborah Dorff Roosevelt Island Historical Society
GEORGETTE SINCLAIR
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff
All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
William Steinway at his Queens mansion, around 1885. Photograph by Frederick Steinway, Astoria, New York. Courtesy of Henry Z. Steinway Archive.
William Steinway appeared in several recent essays (the Queensboro Bridge, LaGuardia airport) and was much involved with the development of Astoria, so I felt it was time for a deeper look.
Steinway was born in Brunswick, Germany in 1835, the fourth son of Henry Engelhard Steinway. After elementary school with special training in languages and music, he apprenticed in a piano factory. With his father and brothers, William came to the United States in 1850 and they all began working for established New York piano firms.
Soon they struck out on their own, going into business as Steinway & Sons in 1853, with a factory at Park and East 53rd. The company grew quickly, secured dozens of patents for innovations in the mechanics of the piano, and moved on to larger manufacturing spaces in the city, even becoming the largest employer in the city in the 1860s.
William was the marketing genius of the family. In 1866, he built a concert hall behind his showroom, on 14th Street, the heart of Manhattan’s theater and shopping district. It was the first Steinway Hall, and an important showcase for artists, a concert hall only surpassed by the building of Carnegie Hall, in 1891.
Astoria and Steinway Village In 1870, Steinway bought 400 acres of land in Astoria, where German immigrants, mostly furniture and cabinet makers, were settling. The Steinways moved the factory there for more space and to keep his workers from the ferment of labor organizing and radicalism, some of which had roiled their own factory. (Their factory was almost burned down in the Draft Riots.) Operations expanded to include key inputs – a sawmill to prepare lumber and a foundry to make the cast iron plates that sit the piano.
In 1880, William and his brother Theodore established a new piano factory in Hamburg, Germany. Theodore headed the German factory, and William returned to Queens. The Hamburg and Queens factories regularly exchanged experience about their patents and technique despite the distance between them, and continue to do so.
Beyond the Astoria factory complex, Steinway created an entire company town. Steinway Village spanned from what is now Ditmars Boulevard up to the East River/Bowery Bay; and from 31st Street to Hazen Street. His diary entries reflect his pride in creating a company town where workers could own brick homes, drink fresh water, and stroll under shade trees on Steinway Avenue—still the main thoroughfare in this part of Queens.
Almost all of his workers were German immigrants, and German was spoken in the factory. Steinway Village had a public school that provided instruction in German as well as English (and one of the country’s first free kindergartens), singing clubs, German beer halls, the Steinway Reformed Church (built in 1890 on land donated by William Steinway, still standing at 41st St and Ditmars), and the Steinway Library, started with books from William’s own collection (now a branch of the Queens Library). Steinway helped develop a network of transportation, including streetcars, trolleys, and horse-car railroads to make the neighborhood more convenient and bring in additional revenue, and a ferry for German workers from across the East River in Yorkville to ferry across to work in the factory.
In 1886, William and George Ehret, a fellow German immigrant who had opened the Hell Gate Brewery in 1866 across the East River in Yorkville, decided to create a beach recreation area nearby where Steinway’s employees could go for entertainment. It was also open to the public, as Steinway hoped other working-class visitors from Manhattan would travel on his streetcars, trolleys, and ferries. In its heyday (1895-1915), 10,000 visitors were showing up each Sunday and it became known as North Beach. During the day it remained a wholesome family retreat, but at night it was the hot spot for young singles to drink beer, dance, and mingle. At one time it was more popular than Brooklyn parks, as “the Coney Island of Queens.”
Getty Images
Steinway was a visionary with big ideas for the city and its transportation systems. In addition to the ferry that transported workers across the East River, he began a tunnel that would connect Queens to Manhattan via underground subway trains (though never finished, today the subway tunnel doing that bears his name). He also helped develop other industrial and business endeavors in the area, buying a natural gas distributor, and investing in several banks.
Daimler One other business adventure was Daimler AG’s first venture into American markets. Steinway met Gottlieb Daimler during a stay in Germany in 1888. Like Daimler, he believed in a bright future for the internal combustion engine automobile. After he returned, plans quickly materialized. On September 29, 1888, Daimler Motor Company of New York was founded and initially produced gasoline and petroleum engines. Steinway and Daimler also started seriously considering the production of automobiles in America, as shipping costs and custom duties prevented import of highly coveted “old-world” automobiles. From 1892 until 1896/97 full copies of the German cars were produced in the premises of the Steinway Astoria plant.
Rapid Transit
During the 1890s, Steinway began a project to extend his company town’s horse-drawn trolley line under the East River and into midtown Manhattan. This project would eventually lead to the IRT Flushing Line. Although he died before the completion of the project, the tunnels that were dug under the East River were named the Steinway Tunnels after him. The dirt removed from the tunnels was formed into a small island in the middle of the East River, now called U Thant Island.
He remained deeply involved in developing public transportation in the City. Steinway spent the last seven years of his life serving on—and chairing—rapid transit commissions that were confronted with every conceivable obstacle to planning a subway for New York City.
Every time the rapid transit commissioners got close to approving a route system there was a catch: legal restrictions, opposition from the owner of existing elevated railways, unhappy property owners, court and political battles, arguments over an above-ground or underground system, and contention over public vs. private funding.
Despite these controversies, Steinway stayed with the project. He had a vision for what New Yorkers needed to get around town speedily: a four-track, largely underground system, with two middle tracks for express trains. “No citizen should have to walk more than three or four blocks to a station,” he told the New York Times. Steinway and his fellow commissioners recommended that trains run on a relatively new and clean power source: electricity.
Scandal Steinway married Regina Roos in April 1861. He was 26 and she 17 and the couple seemed deeply in love. The couple had three children; George, Paula, and Alfred, who was born in 1869. In 1875, he learned that Alfred was not his son. Regina’s affairs were a severe trauma for him and, after learning of her infidelities (Alfred’s father was not her only lover) in September 1875, heard many sordid details over the ensuing months until the couple divorced in August 1876. After the divorce, Alfred moved with his mother to France. Steinway later happily remarried.
Final Note
Steinway died in 1896, at the scarcely ripe old age of 61. He was ambitious and aggressive and successful. He did not rise to the level of the great Robber-Barons of the age, and was never condemned as they were. He was fascinated by the emerging City, and by the City’s need for public transportation and was a vigorous advocate for the infrastructure that would support it. He was an immigrant and German to the core. All in all, a pretty fair New Yorker.
Ed Litcher, Nina Lublin, Jay Jacobson, Hara Reiser, Andy Sparberg, Aron Eisenpreiss all got it right
Stephen Blank
RIHS June I, 2021
Sources
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff
All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
On the typical apartment house, the front door is a cookie-cutter item, straight out of a catalog. But 7 Gracie Square, just off East End Avenue, is hardly typical, the project of a muralist who got into real estate.
The double doors and flanking ironwork are a frenzy of swirling shapes in brass and iron, plated with zinc, nickel and cadmium, populated by gazelles, elephants and sinuous plants. Now these 1929 masterworks of metal gleam in the north light from Carl Schurz Park, reinstalled earlier this month after a restoration.
The maisonette entrance to the left bears, in intricate script, the name Crisp, for this was the project of Arthur W. Crisp, a Canadian muralist who made good, very good, until the Depression hit. Born in 1881, Crisp came to New York around 1900, and studied at the Art Students League. By the 1910s he was getting mural commissions for theaters, institutions and private houses.
His private work was free and playful, but his public murals tended toward the conventional; in 1933 Lewis Mumford offhandedly described one as “sweet and dreadful.” Nevertheless, Crisp did well enough to buy real estate, including some old buildings on far East 84th Street. He bought in early 1928, just before the stubby dead end was renamed Gracie Square.
Crisp retained George B. Post & Sons, along with Rosario Candela, and they designed a tepid Art Deco facade of red brick, with vertical runs of brick set at an angle.
Magnificent metalwork doors, recently restored, distinguish 7 Gracie Square on far East 84th Street.Credit…Marilynn K. Yee/The New York Times
Renting began in the spring of 1929, when four- to seven-room apartments cost from $160 to $290 per month. The building had a gym and extra maids’ rooms. Some idea of the residents may be gained from a 1930 account in The New York Times: a tenant, Fanny Parsons, said that a handbag with $45,000 in jewelry had been stolen from her apartment. It turned out that she had left it in a taxicab. Whoops!
Mrs. Parsons and her $45,000 bag of jewelry went in and out through two brass-framed doors decorated with tendrils of nickel-plated bronze sprouting from howdahs borne by bronze elephants and coiling to fill the space.
Above the doors, a bowed-out tympanum of cadium-coated cast iron showcases two gazelles surrounded by a panoply of spiraling plants, all in a deep, rich silver.
Just inside the main doors, the radiator grilles are square-rigged ships of hammered iron plated with nickel.
Do not fail to notice the cunning little grilles on the doors of the flanking maisonettes. The one to the left with “Crisp” intricately worked into the metalwork was apparently the artist’s apartment, and directories list him here at the sub-number, 8 Gracie Square. The 1930 census records Crisp as paying $833 per month, far more than anyone else there, which is hard to explain. One tradition in the building has it that he occupied the penthouse, complete with organ loft.
A final touch is on the inner doors: The brass kick plate is cut in the shape of a rolling form called a Vitruvian wave, the whole package a perfect demonstration of the metalworker’s art. And what metalworker was that, exactly?
The apartment building at 7 Gracie Square, designed by George B. Post & Sons, was a project of Arthur W. Crisp, a Canadian muralist.Credit…Museum of the City of New York
Crisp is not known to have designed in metal, and the doors call to mind the work of the French designer Edgar Brandt, who had a few other commissions in New York, like the magnificent doors of the Cheney Brothers’ showroom at Madison and 34th.
The 1920s were good times in real estate. Crisp was on a roll, and in early 1929 engaged the Post firm for two more 15-story apartment houses, although these were not built. In May, five months before the stock-market crash, he bought 238 acres upstate. But the 1930s were not so swell, both for real estate and for business in general; in 1934 he appeared on a panel promoting the increased use of artwork in architecture.
And then, in 1935, the bank took back 7 Gracie Square, metalwork and all, at a foreclosure auction, paying $625,000 against the loan balance of $733,000. Crisp and his wife, Grace, also an artist, moved to Charlton Street.
In 1945 the tenants bought 7 Gracie for $500,000. The facade was rebuilt in 1993. The doors did not become a problem until recently, when the plating began to rub off, allowing the iron underneath to rust. In 2010 the co-op board retained Conservation Solutions of Washington to inspect and analyze the doors. Mark Rabinowitz, the company’s vice president, thinks it is likely the metalwork is by Brandt.
Suzanne Charity lives in Crisp’s old maisonette apartment, and has served on the board. She was active in an earlier renovation campaign, and says the building hired craftsmen in France to make gates, radiator covers and other details for the lobby that had always been lacking. The new fixtures are indistinguishable from the originals.
It is easy to pass by short little Gracie Square, until you know of the striking doors.
THE FDR PARK IS NOW FULLY ACCESSIBLE TO ALL WITH NEW LIFT AND UNDER TREE PAVING
EVER SINCE THE PARK OPENED IN 2012 (AND FOR MANY YEARS BEFORE) ISLANDERS COMPLAINED THAT THE PARK WAS NOT PLANNED TO BE FULLY ACCESSIBLE TO PERSONS WITH LIMITED MOBILITY.
A NEW STAIR LIFT HAS JUST BEEN INSTALLED ALONG WITH NEW PAVING UNDER THE LINDEN TREES.
WE HOPE THAT THIS WILL ENCOURAGE ALL TO VISIT AND FULLY ENJOY THE PARK.
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff All image are copyrighted (c)
Sources
STREETSCAPES CHRISTOPHER GRAY NEW YORK TIMES (C)
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
Underfoot all over New York City are late 19th and early 20th century manhole covers embossed with unusual shapes and designs. There’s a practical purpose for this: raised detailing helped prevent people from slipping (and horses from skidding) as they traversed Gotham’s streets in wet weather.
They’re also a form of branding. The city’s many foundries of the era manufactured manhole and coal hole covers. Each foundry company seemed to have chosen a specific design or look to represent them.
And let’s not leave out the artistry that went into these. Manhole covers aren’t typically thought of as works of art, but there’s creativity and imagination in the different designs we walk over and tend not to notice.
J.B. and J.M. Cornell, who operated an ironworks foundry at 26th Street and 11th Avenue, added bubble-like details and smaller dots to their covers, as seen on the example (at top) found in the East 70s near Central Park. They also added swirly motifs on the sides, prettying up these iron lids and making the name and address easier to read.
McDougall and Potter, on the other hand, went for a classic star to decorate this cover on East 80th Street (second photo above). This foundry on West 55th Street also chose bars and dots, within which they included the company name and address.
This cover (above) on 23rd Street near Fifth Avenue, likely by Jacob Mark & Sons on Worth Street, once has colored glass embedded in that hexagram design. A century and then some of foot and vehicle traffic wore them down and pushed some out.
Could those be flower petals decorating the hexagram shape on this cover, also by the Mark foundry? Located near Broadway and Houston Street, it’s unique and charming, especially with the tiny stars dotting the lower end.
RUTH AND IRVING BERDY From what I heard the weather was 87 and humid for the rooftop wedding at the St. George Hotel in Brooklyn
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff
All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
EPHEMERAL NEW YORK (C)
Tags: 19th Century Manhole Covers, beautiful manhole covers, Manhole cover art, manhole covers New York City, Old Manhole Covers New York City, vintage manhole covers, Why Manhole Covers Have Designs
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff
All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
WE KNOW OF JAMES RENWICK, JR. AS THE ARCHITECT OF THE SMALLPOX HOSPITAL & OUR LIGHTHOUSE. THE GRACE CHURCH WAS ALSO OF HIS DESIGN.
Henry Brevoort’s country estate engulfed 86 acres between East 9th and 18th Streets and Fifth Avenue to the Bowery. Wealthy and apparently stubborn, when Broadway was extended to meet the Bloomingdale Road he demanded that it take a sharp bend at 10th Street so as not to intrude on his land. And because the family house sat directly upon the proposed site of 11th Street, between Broadway and the Bowery, he prevented the opening of 11th Street throughout the 1830’s. But following Brevoort’s death in 1841, his son, Henry, Jr., began selling off the family lands.
Grace Episcopal Church had been located at Broadway and Rector Street since its organization in 1808. Rector Thomas House Taylor and his congregation were considering an uptown move, following the northern migration of its fashionable members. Two years after Henry Brevoort Sr.’s death, the trustees bought the large plot of land at the northeast corner of Broadway and East 10th Street.
It is possible that Henry Brevoort, Jr. worked a deal into the transaction. His nephew, 23-year old James Renwick Jr., was an engineer with a bent towards architecture. An engineer on the massive Croton Reservoir project, completed in 1842, he was responsible for its hulking Egyptian Revival design. He had also designed a fountain in Bowling Green. Nevertheless, with no formal training his architectural credentials were sorely lacking.
Renwick was given the commission to design the new Grace Church. Rev. Taylor had spent extensive time in Europe touring the great Gothic cathedrals and it was most likely he who influenced Renwick’s design choice. Gothic Revival architecture was relatively new and Grace Church would be the first significant structure in the style in Manhattan. The masterful white marble church was completed in 1846, followed closely by the rectory. Sitting back within a grassy yard encircled by a magnificent Gothic Revival iron fence, the charming marble house echoed the church looming above it. Renwick’s skill at design resulted in a romantic edifice that refused to be overshadowed by its cathedral-like neighbor.
Although having the appearance of a cozy cottage, the rectory was essentially a mansion. Renwick hid the actual symmetry of the floorplan by adding different faceted bays on either side of the centered entrance. Gothic tracery, spires and crockets, and pointed arch windows combined to form an excruciatingly picturesque structure.
The charm of the rectory was deserving of its own postcard around the turn of the last century. from the collection of the New York Public Library
The charm of the rectory was deserving of its own postcard around the turn of the last century. from the collection of the New York Public Library
Grace Church was the second wealthiest Episcopal Church in New York, after Trinity Church. In his 1882 New York by Gaslight, James D. McCabe, Jr. would point out, “At the morning service a greater display of wealth and fashion is presented here than at any other city church. Grace Church has been the scene of more fashionable weddings and funerals than any other place of worship.”
Rectors of such churches were highly paid. They and their families lived in a style similar to their millionaire congregants. Many owned country estates and traveled to Europe or fashionable resorts in the summer months when their churches were closed.
Rev. Henry Codman Potter was rector in 1875 when his wife, the former Eliza Rogers, planned an extended trip abroad. She placed an ad in the New York Herald on September 30 hoping to find positions for excess servants who would not be needed in her absence:
804 Broadway, Grace Church Rectory–A lady, going to Europe, wishes to obtain situations for a cook, a seamstress and lady’s maid, and a waitress, whom she can highly recommend. Call for one week.
In 1880 James Renwick, Jr. was called back to design Grace House, a seamlessly matching 30-foot wide, three story structure that connected the church to the rectory. The New-York Tribune reported on August 10 that it would have “a handsome white marble front, each story possessing a well-proportioned bay window. Completed in 1881, it completed the country-like yard.
Renwick’s Grace House perfectly complimented the rectory and the church. from the collection of the New-York Historical Society.
Henry C. Potter was elected Assistant Bishop of New York on September 27, 1883 and the rectory next became home to Rev. William Reed Huntington. He and his wife, the former Theresa Reynolds, had two daughters, Margaret and Theresa, and a son, Francis. Like their predecessors, they moved among society’s elite.
During the debutante season of 1885-86 the rectory was the scene of a glittering entertainment. On December 30, 1885 The New York Times reported “There was a tea and reception yesterday afternoon in honor of Dr. Huntington’s second daughter, Miss Theresa, at the Grace Church Rectory. The parlors in which the guests were received were hung with evergreens and decorated with flowers. Miss Theresa, who reached her eighteenth birthday a few days since, wore a white satin dress, with a cluster of roses at the waist and diamond ornaments.” The guest list included society names like Depew, Tiffany, Dix, Reid, Duncan, and Kingsland.
Among Huntington’s staff in 1893 were assistant ministers Rev. Hubert M. Wells and Rev. George H. Bottome. The kind-hearted men became victims of a masterful scam artist that year. George Stabell traveled alone to New York from Denmark in 1891 at the age of 14. With no friends and no money, according to The Sun, “he turned his good looks, easy manners, and quick intelligence to account.” He realized that the clergy were easy marks for a sad story and lived comfortably off his scams.
One-third of the rectory was enveloped in ivy in this late 19th century stereopticon view. from the collection of the New York public Library
In January 1893 he turned his attentions to Grace Church. The Sun reported a month later that he told Wells and Bottome “that he had not lived an exemplary life…He admitted he had been playing the races and living a fast life. ‘Now I want to reform,’ said he, with tears in his eyes…’I want to be a Christian and a gentleman. I’m out of money and have no place to eat or sleep. Give me a chance, just one chance.'”
Moved by the repentant teen’s story, Wells took him to a boarding house on West 31st Street and paid a week’s rent in advance. He gave the boy letters of recommendation to use in finding a job.
The following week Stabell returned. He said while he had made friends at the boarding house, he still was unable to find a job. Wells gave him $10 to pay the next week’s rent (about $295 today). The very next day the boy returned, telling Rev. Wells:
A strange thing happened last night. When I went to my room I found there my brother, my own brother, ragged, penniless, and cold. His hat was gone, his shoes were flapping on his feet, and his clothes were in rags. He begged for money. What could I do? I bought him a ticket back to Baltimore, and with what was left I got him a pair of shoes, a hat, and something to eat. Did I do wrong?”
Stabell had so carefully planned his story that he knew the exact amount of a ticket to Baltimore. Wells gave him another $10.
The Sun reported, “The next day the boy was back again, this time to see the other assistant, Mr. Bottome. It was bitter cold, and he had on no overcoat. ‘I didn’t tell Mr. Wells last night,’ said he, ‘but I had to pawn my overcoat to get my brother home. Now I’m almost frozen without it.” He needed money to get his coat out of pawn.
At a meeting with clergy of other churches it was discovered how widely Stabell had been carrying out his scams. The ministers had a policeman “come and talk to the boy to frighten him by threats of arrest and imprisonment.”
The end to the teen’s infamous career began on February 11 when he came to Wells for another $10. “He got it on promising to return $3 of it, his necessary expenses being but $7,” explained The Sun. “By this time the clergyman had been to the boy’s boarding place and discovered that instead of being busy in the morning trying to find work he was lying abed; also that he usually came home about 3 A.M.” Stabell did not return that afternoon with the $3 as promised.
That night Wells went to the boy’s room and waited until 2:00 in the morning before giving up and going home. Stabell showed up at the rectory the next morning and Wells “taxed him with treachery and deceit.” The teen “confessed, and begged for forgiveness with all the dramatic power which he possesses.” He was told to return the next day.
He returned, without the $3, and Wells and Bottomes “had a long talk with him which resulted in a conviction on their part that he was a hopeless case.” While Bottome detained him, Wells swore out a warrant at Jefferson Market Court for the theft of $3. The Sun reported that at Stabell’s arraignment, “He begged for just one more chance before he was sent to prison, but Mr. Wells had been through it all before and he declined to be deceived again.” None of the other clergymen he had duped would answer the plea-filled notes he sent from jail. One said “He could make one believe that he was a saint in ten minutes, no matter how much appearances might be against him.”
A disturbing incident occurred on April 27, 1894. Policeman Sullivan arrested John Sullivan, described by the New-York Tribune as “a homeless, insane man, fifty years old,” after he was caught “pushing his fist through the windows of Grace Church rectory.” By the time the officer arrived, he had broken several of the panes of glass.
In 1899 Rev. Huntington added a notable ornament to the rectory garden–an ancient Roman jar. In his comments in the Year Book that year he explained that when excavations in Rome were being dug for the Rectory of the Church of St. Paul, “some six of seven terra-cotta jars” dating from Nero’s reign were discovered about 30 or 40 feet below the surface. Two were brought to the surface.
When I was in Rome in 1884, the two jars, covered with ivy, were standing one on either side of the entrance to the church. I was hard-hearted enough to urge upon Dr. Nevin, the Rector, the propriety of his showing his appreciation of all that Grace Church had done toward the building of St. Paul’s by giving us one of his two jars; and he was kind-hearted enough to acquiesce in the suggestion.
When the relic finally arrived in New York a bronze mounting was created for it and it was placed in the garden where it sits today.
At around 10:00 on the night of February 7, 1900 servants discovered a man in a room in the basement. The Sun reported, “He seemed to be very much startled, but when one of the servants returned with a policeman, he pretended to be intoxicated.” Burglar tools were found on him and he was locked up “as a suspicious person.”
The incident was a precursor to a more significant incident one year later. On the morning of April 30, 1901 a maid entered the dining room to find silverware littered over the dining room carpeting. “It was evident to her at once,” reported The New York Times, “not only that burglars had gotten in, but that they had been frightened off, without having been able to take all that they had prepared for removal.”
The thieves had carefully plotted their heist down to the point of apparently watching through a dining room window to see where the maid hid the key to the silver safe. They had entered through a basement door, as the intruder the previous year had, and stealthily crept upstairs by the light of a candle. That they had been scared off was evidenced by the candle, a box of matches and the chisel they had used to jimmy the basement door, all of which they left behind in their haste.
Despite their rapid departure, they managed to carry off “knives, spoons, salt cellars, and other small pieces which could be stuffed into pockets or carried away under a waistcoat or coat.” The article noted “The unfortunate feature of the robbery is that Dr. Huntington lost through it a number of heirlooms, which as he explained last evening, had been in the family a long time.”
The detectives and patrolmen on duty in the area received a “lecture” from Police Captain Chapman who called it “a shame that men in his precinct should have allowed a burglary to be committed in so prominent a place.”
More than a century later James Renwick Jr.’s charming rectory, along with its garden complex behind the cast iron fence, is a Victorian time capsule. The rectory warrants almost as much attention for its architectural beauty and significance as does the church beside it.
TUESDAY PHOTO OF THE DAY
ON THIS DAY, JUNE 8th, 1941 Ruth Katz married Irving Berdy Our love to you, Judy, Alan and Elle
MONDAY PHOTO OF THE DAY
City Hall Broadway and Park Row ANDY SPARBERG, HARA REISER, ARON EISENPREISS, JAY JACOBSON, LAURA HUSSEY, ARLENE BESSENOFFF, NINA LUBLIN ALL GOT IT RIGHT
Text by Judith Berdy Thanks to Bobbie Slonevsky for her dedication to Blackwell’s Almanac and the RIHS Thanks to Deborah Dorff for maintaining our website Edited by Melanie Colter and Deborah Dorff Sources
DAYTONIAN IN MANHATTAN
FUNDING PROVIDED BY ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE GRANTS CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE BEN KALLOS DISCRETIONARY FUNDING THRU DYCD
