Dec

18

Thursday, December 18, 2025 – OVER A MILE OF PATHS MADE FOR SLEIGH RIDING

By admin

This ForgottenStretch

of Central Park was

OriginallyIntended to be a

Road That Celebrated Winter

In the 1850s, the designers of Central Park, Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux, seemed to anticipate this wintertime beauty. They gave thought to park features that could enhance the charms of frigid temperatures and convince New Yorkers to enjoy the park in all seasons.

The skating pond Olmsted and Vaux created accomplished this. It was a smash hit when the pond opened in 1858, not long after the two designers got the go-ahead to build their vision of a park. The pond attracted an estimated 30,000 people to try out this new form of recreation.

Their other idea was more atmospheric: a long scenic road spanning 72nd to 102nd Street “along the low grounds west of the reservoirs,” according to an 1858 New York Times story. This appropriately named road was called the “Winter Drive.”

The Winter Drive would consist of a mile and a half of thick rows of evergreens, so sleigh riders would feel like they were in snow-covered conifer countryside, not an urban park.

An 1858 New York Daily Herald article summed up the proposal.

“Large open glades of grass are introduced among these plantations of evergreens, as the effect aimed at is not so much of a drive through a thick forest, crowded with tall spindling trees, as through a richly wooded country, in which the single trees and copses have had plenty of space for developing their distinctive characteristics to advantage.”

The Winter Drive would be marked by its own bridge near West 82nd Street, Winterdale Arch. This graceful stone bridge, constructed in 1861, “is named for its location on the Winter Drive, between Seventy-Second Street and 102nd Street,” states a post from NYC Department of Records & Information Services.

“When planning the west side of the park, Olmsted and Vaux intended for this section to be planted with a variety of evergreens, to add color throughout the winter for carriage- and sleigh-riders,” per the department.

In the early years, the Winter Drive was put to good use. Sleigh riding for leisure was a popular winter activity in the 19th century city, and a drive on steel rails must have been a thrilling way to experience this 843-acre green space wonderland.

Unfortunately, all the conifers Olmsted and Vaux planted along the Winter Drive in 1861 were lost by the end of the century, states the Central Park Conservatory.

Over time, it seems that the Winter Drive name was forgotten. Winter Drive was absorbed into West Drive, which winds along the west side of the park.

Walk along the West Drive today, however, and you’ll see conifer trees similar to those that would have lined the drive in the post-Civil War era.

In the 1970s, “philanthropist Arthur Ross returned pine trees to the area, funding the planting of the Arthur Ross Pinetum just to the north,” states the Central Park Conservatory.

“Additional evergreen plantings by the Central Park Conservancy have also returned the look and feel of the ‘Winter Drive’ to this area of the Park.”

It might be hard to find a sleigh these days. But walk along this stretch of Central Park after a snowfall, and you’ll see the newer conifers laden with fluffy snow—part of a lovely winter landscape park visitors in the 1860s to 1890s would have well recognized.

YOUR DOG CAN DRESS LIKE OSCAR. DOG COATS AVAILABLE IN 3 SIZES AT THE RIHS VISITOR KIOSK.

CREDITS

EPHEMERAL NEW YORK

[Second image: hand-colored woodcut of a Thulstrup illustration; third image: MCNY, 93.1.1.17790; fourth image: MCNY, F2011.33.922; fifth image: NYPL Digital Collections]

Tags: Central Park in winterCentral Park The Winter DriveEarly Central Park FeaturesSleigh Riding Winter Drive Central Parksleighs in Central ParkSleighs in New York City 19th CenturyWinter Drive in Central ParkWinter Drive Olmsted Vaux Central Park
Posted in central parkTransit | 5 Comments »

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

17

Wednesday, December 17, 2025 – CANAL STREET HAS AN INTERESTING HISTORY

By admin

What Happened to the Canal

that Gave

Canal Street its Name?

But Canal Street in New York City? It doesn’t exactly conjure up romance. True, an actual canal did exist here in the early 1800s. It was pleasantly designed—surrounded by trees, crossed by a footbridge dubbed the “kissing bridge,” and flanked on either side by tidy houses.

But whatever positive feelings New Yorkers may have had about the canal at first disappeared quickly. The water it carried was fetid, the ditch became an open sewer, and the residents of the newly opened Canal Street were relieved when it was permanently covered over.

The story of this short-lived canal starts in the 1790s, when New York City was grappling with a serious drinking water problem.

During its days as a Dutch colonial outpost, residents got their water from the many streams that crossed Lower Manhattan. By the time the English occupied Manhattan, a freshwater pond known as Collect Pond (above), roughly centered in today’s Chinatown, became a main source of safe water.

Collect Pond was picturesque, 60 feet deep, and fed by an underground spring, according to NYC Parks. Families picnicked beside its shore, and when the pond froze in the winter, skaters would take to the ice.

But as the 18th century progressed, industry began using the pond as a dumping ground. Waste from tanneries, slaughterhouses, breweries, and other manufacturers eventually transformed Collect Pond into a foul-smelling body of water that bred disease.

In the early 1800s, the city decided to drain this former water source, then fill it in and turn the new land into useable real estate. To properly drain the pond, a wide ditch needed to be built that would carry away the foul waters to the Hudson River.

By 1810, city officials began engineering “a plank-sided canal eight feet wide following a straight line from Centre Street to the Hudson, with a roadway on both sides,” wrote Oliver E. Allen in a 2013 article in the Tribeca Trib.

The canal had a promising start, with its charming footbridge and tree-lined promenade, states NYC Parks. “The canal was popular among the residents of what was by now a lively neighborhood surrounding it,” wrote Allen. That neighborhood would have been on the outskirts of the city center.

But thanks to sluggish water flow, the canal (above in 1811, at Broadway) became more like a cesspool. Stagnant water and rancid odors made nearby residents disgusted and angry.

By 1820, the decision was made to cover the canal and bury it under the street. Residents complained that it still emitted a foul smell, which makes sense, because the former canal was never actually filled in. Enclosed in a brick-arched tunnel, it became the city’s first sewer, according to New York water ecology organization NYCh2o.org.

As time went on, Canal Street’s fortunes didn’t change. Thanks to its proximity to the Five Points slum—built on the marshy land of the former Collect Pond—the street developed a rougher edge. Property values plunged, though commercial activity kept Canal Street a main business artery.

These days, Canal Street serves as kind of Lower Manhattan demarcation line. On one end, it’s the southern border of SoHo and the northern end of Chinatown. On the other end, it divides SoHo and Tribeca.

Each end of Canal Street still has a handful of early 19th century residences, the kind that would have lined the street when the canal existed. The canal is history, but the houses that once flanked it have been standing for roughly two centuries.

PHOTO BY JUDITH BERDY

CREDIT

EPHEMERAL NEW YORK

Tags: Canal Street early 1800sCanal Street Name OriginsHow Canal Street NYC Got Its NameWhat Happened to the Canal on Canal Street NYCWhen did Canal Street OpenWhen Was the Canal in NYC Drained
Posted in Lower Manhattan | 11 Comments »

THE COMMENTS ARE REALLY INTERESTING

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

16

Tuesday, December 16, 2025 – THE BROTHERS OF THE FAMOUS PULLMAN RAIL CARS

By admin

Albert Benton Pullman:

Gilded Age Entrepreneur

Albert Benton Pullman: Gilded Age Entrepreneur

December 9, 2025 by Editorial Staff 

Simon Cordery’s Gilded Age Entrepreneur: The Curious Life of Albert Benton Pullman (Cornell University Press, 2025) illuminates the fascinating and chaotic business world of Albert Pullman (1828-1893).

The influential but little-known older brother of George Pullman (1831-1897) and the craftsman of the family, Albert designed the first luxurious Pullman railroad cars and hosted promotional trips to show them off. In those heady early days, he met national business and political leaders and hired the first Pullman porters.

For the earliest of it’s 100 years (1867-1968) the Pullman Company was known for its sleeping and dining cars. These were designed after the Erie Canal packet boats the Pullmans’ saw in their youths in Albion, NY, the county seat canal town of Orleans County.

Around 1800 the Pullman family had migrated from New England to New York and found their way to Onondaga, where new settlers were exploiting the salt springs on former Onondaga land.

The brothers’ parents Lewis (a carpenter) and Emily Caroline Minton Pullman were married id briefly in Auburn, NY, on Owasco Lake, one of the Finger Lakes in Central New York’s Cayuga County, where Albert was born. They moved to Albion after the Erie Canal was well established, probably to avoid the higher costs in the boom-town of Auburn.

Palace Cars, Pullman Porters, and Great Strikes

Albert and George’s first grand “palace car,” named (as a canal boat would be) The Pioneer, was finished in 1864 in Chicago. In 1867, the Pullmans introduced a “hotel on wheels,” the President, a sleeper with an attached kitchen and dining car. The food and service were said to have rivaled the best restaurants of the day.

As sales exploded, their labor force grew. They built a company town near Chicago following the Great Railroad Strike of 1877. That ultimately led to the national 1894 Pullman Strike over high company town rents and low wages, which occurred the year after Albert died, and three years before George died.

Notably, that strike engulfed Buffalo, NY, where the American Railway Union (ARU) local joined the nationwide boycott of Pullman cars. They halted rail traffic which led to clashes and federal intervention. The strike was one of the inspirations of Labor Day as a national holiday.

No biography of the company’s founders can fail to mention the Pullman Company was also widely known for it’s use of Black American workers as “Pullman Porters,” who were themselves American cultural icons. They performed luxury services for wealthy white travelers on trains, who often derisively called them all “George” or other epithets.

Despite severe racism, long hours and low wages, the job was seen as one of the best opportunities for Black men due to its stable income and culminated in the formation of the first successful Black labor union, the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters, founded in 1925, long after the death of the Pullman brothers.

Led by A. Philip Randolph (1889-1979), the Brotherhood fought for better conditions, helped many men and their descendants reach the Black middle class, and inspired Civil Rights Movement leaders.

Albert and George as Entrepreneurs

Albert and George Pullman made a formidable team, they supported Republican candidates and took advantage of workers and their political connections and contracts.

But as the Pullman Company grew along white American workers’ resistance to exploitation nationally, Albert Pullman’s role shrank. His self-interest inspired more close association with the returning power of the Democratic Party. He turned to his own investment portfolio, often with disastrous results.

Beginning with the industrial laundry that cleaned sleeping-car linens, Albert appeared before the U.S. Supreme Court after a catastrophic insurance investment, ran afoul of federal banking regulations, and failed in an attempt to corner wheat futures.

With evermore unsuccessful speculations, Albert was tempted by illegal land sales and entered exploiting silver mines.

Finally, his own family in crisis and his relationship with George shattered, Albert Pullman launched into one last round of adventurous investments – including both the early electricity and telephone industries – with mixed results.

Although it largely misses his role in the labor and race struggles of the era, Gilded Age Entrepreneur does instead focuses on the idea that Albert Pullman embodied the small-time investors who were legion after the Civil War.

“From banking and insurance to manufacturing and mining, a host of hopeful dreamers like Albert Pullman fueled the circulation of capital by forging political connections, creating and losing businesses, issuing shares, and longing for profit,” the book press materials say.

Although much of this history is focused on Chicago (where he made significant arts investments with his wealth), the book is well-placed on a New York bookshelf as a biography of those against whom New York workers and Black Americans struggled for dignity in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

PHOTO BY JUDITH BERDY

CREDITS

NEW YORK ALMANACK
JUDITH BERDY

Book Purchases made through this Amazon link support the New York Almanack’s mission to report new publications relevant to New York State. 

Read more about railroad history in New York State.

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

15

Monday, December 15, 2025 – THE ARTISTIC BEAUTY OF SNOW IN NEW YORK

By admin

SNOW SCENES

FROM

EPHEMERAL NEW YORK

Playing in the snow in Tompkins Square Park

Is this painting from 1934 or 2013? Tompkins Square Park and the colorful row of buildings bordering it on East 10th Street have barely changed in 89 years in Saul Kovner’s “Tompkins Park, N.Y. City.”

Kovner was a Russia-born painter; like so many other struggling artists, he worked for the New Deal’s Public Works of Art Project in the 1930s.

“The PWAP encouraged their commissioned artists to capture ‘the American Scene,’ and in this painting Kovner conveys strong messages of community spirit and American values,” states the web site for the Smithsonian Institution, which owns this painting.

“Children and adults enjoy winter in the park, building snowmen and playing with sleds; the presence of the Stars and Stripes in the center of the work places this as a uniquely American scene.”

A winter twilight in the snow on 57th Street

This is 57th Street in 1902, painted by Robert Henri, whose Ashcan School work depicted a moody New York in all of its grit and glory.

Could the cross street with the elevated train be Sixth Avenue? It would have been close to the Art Students League, where Henri taught.

Blue snow on the Battery in wintertime

No one paints New York City in the winter, in all of its blue and white harshness and beauty, quite like George Bellows.

Looking at “Blue Snow, the Battery,” from 1910, you can just feel the chill coming off New York Harbor, and how much colder it must be for the men standing in those shadows

You can practically feel the biting wind and snow in this raw 1911 New York winter street scene

There’s a lot of white in this depiction of a blustery winter day in the New York City of 1911: white snow on the street, stoops, and light poles; white-gray skies filling with factory smoke (or smoke from ship smokestacks?) across a grayish river.

Then there’s the violent white brushstrokes of howling wind against the red brick buildings. The wind is painted so viscerally, you can almost feel the icy snow and biting cold (and sympathize with the woman shielding her face in her coat, holding on to her hat).

“City Snow Scene” is an early work of Stuart Davis, a Pennsylvania native born in 1892 who is much better known as a Modernist painter. As a 17-year-old launching a career in New York, he fell under the thrall of early 20th century Ashcan artists and their gritty depictions of urban life.

The painting was auctioned by in 2012 by Christie’s, which had this to say about it: “Through bravura brushwork and a simplified muted palette, Davis succeeds in rendering a dreary winter’s day in lower Manhattan.”

“With a generous application of whites, Davis works up the surfaces to portray the texture of the snow which is juxtaposed with the more carefully applied reds he employs to develop the architecture in the background,” per Christie’s website.

“Broad, heavily applied strokes of black are the only device Davis employs to represent the pedestrians with the exception of a few simple touches of orange that delineate the faces of the primary figures in the foreground.”

It’s how a New York City winter used to be—and is once again in winter 2025

The Cordova family is facing an incredibly difficult time after losing their home in a fire on December 1st. Thankfully, no one was home, and their cat, Nemo, escaped safely. However, everything inside the house was destroyed, leaving them with nothing. They now need help to replace essential items like clothing, shoes, warm coats, personal hygiene products, and prescriptions that were lost.

This is a heartbreaking situation, and any support you can offer will make a real difference. Your contribution will go directly toward helping Miriam and Armando as they begin to rebuild their lives. Thank you for considering this.

Best regards,

https://gofund.me/709cf4410

PHOTO BY JUDITH BERDY

CREDITS

EPHEMERAL NEW YORK
JUDITH BERDY

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

13

Weekend, December 13-14, 2025 – A FUN TIME WANDERING AROUND RUTHERFORD PLACE

By admin

STUYVESANT SQUARE PARK

WIKIPEDIA*

Stuyvesant Square is the name of both a park and its surrounding neighborhood in the New York City borough of Manhattan. The park is located between 15th Street17th Street, Rutherford Place, and Nathan D. Perlman Place (formerly Livingston Place). Second Avenue divides the park into two halves, east and west, and each half is surrounded by the original cast-iron fence.[1]

The neighborhood is roughly bounded by 14th Street to the south, 18th or 19th Street to the north, First Avenue to the east, and Third Avenue to the west.[2][3][4] It is part of Manhattan Community Board 6.[5]

Geography

Manhattan Community Board 6 does not mark neighborhood boundaries on its map, but centers “Stuyvesant Park” in the area south of 20th Street, north of 14th Street, east of Third Avenue, and west of First Avenue.[6] In city documents, New York City census tract 48.97 (later known as tract 48) has been used as an approximation for Stuyvesant Park.[7] To the east of the neighborhood is Stuyvesant Town, to the west is the Union Square area, and to the south is the East Village.[2][8]

For its entry on “Stuyvesant Square and North,” the American Institute of Architects‘ AIA Guide to New York City uses the area east of Third Avenue, from 14th Street to 23rd Street. In AIA Guide, Stuyvesant Square is adjacent to Union Square and Gramercy Park to the west, the East Village to the south, and Kips Bay to the north.[9]

The Stuyvesant Park Neighborhood Association serves residents “from East 14th Street north to East 23rd Street and from Stuyvesant Town west toward Irving Place and Gramercy Park.”[10]

In 1836, Peter Gerard Stuyvesant (1778–1847) – the great-great-grandson of Peter Stuyvesant[11] – and his wife Helen (or Helena) Rutherfurd reserved four acres of the Stuyvesant farm and sold it for a token five dollars to the City of New York as a public park, originally to be called Holland Square, with the proviso that the City of New York build a fence around it. As time passed, however, no fence was constructed, and in 1839, Stuyvesant’s family sued the City to cause it to enclose the land. Not until 1847 did the City begin to improve the park by erecting the magnificent, 2800 foot long cast-iron fence, which still stands as the oldest cast-iron fence in New York City.[12] (The oldest fence in New York is that around Bowling Green.[13]) In 1850 two fountains completed the landscaping, and the park was formally opened to the public. The public space joined St. John’s Square (no longer extant), the recently formed Washington Square and the private Gramercy Park as residential squares around which it was expected New York’s better neighborhoods would be built.

In the early 1900s, Stuyvesant Square was among the city’s most fashionable addresses. The Stuyvesant Building, at 17 Livingston Place on the eastern edge of the square, was home to the publisher George PutnamHarper’s Bazaar editor Elizabeth Jordan and Elizabeth Custer, the widow of General George Armstrong Custer.[14]

The opening of St. George’s Church, located on Rutherford Place and 16th Street (built on land obtained from Peter Stuyvesant, 1848–1856; burnt down in 1865;[11] remodeled by C.O.Blesch and L. Eidlitz, 1897)[9][15] and the Friends Meeting House and Seminary (to the southwest) (1861, Charles Bunting) attracted more residents to the area around the park. The earliest existing houses in the district, in the Greek Revival style, date to 1842–43, when the city’s residential development was first moving north of 14th Street, but the major growth in the area occurred in the 1850s.[1] Fashionable houses were still being built as late as 1883, when Richard Morris Hunt‘s Sidney Webster House at 245 East 17th Street – now the East End Temple synagogue[16] – was completed,[1] but already German and Irish immigrants, had begun moving into new rowhouses and brownstones in the neighborhood, followed by JewishItalian and Slavic immigrants.[2][17]

Other than Beth Israel, other hospitals were located in the neighborhood as well. The New York Infirmary for Women and Children was founded at 321 East 15th Street by the pioneering woman physician, Dr. Elizabeth Blackwell.[17] The New York Lying-In Hospital on Second Avenue at 17th Street, is now condominiums, but the Hospital for Joint Diseases, a unit of NYU Medical Center is located across the avenue. Other now non-existent hospitals included the Salvation Army‘s William Booth Memorial Hospital, Manhattan General, and St. Andrew’s Convalescent Hospital.[17] Because of the number of hospitals in the district, there were many doctor’s offices on the side streets, along with quacks and midwives who preyed upon the area’s immigrant population.[17]

Stuyvesant Square Park, like many other city parks, was extensively rehabilitated in a more populist manner during the 1930s, when the 19th-century plan was modified by Parks Commissioner Robert Moses‘ landscape architect Gilmore D. Clarke, with the addition of comfort stations, playgrounds and other built amenities. The park reopened in 1937; the 1980s saw restorations of the two 1884 fountains, the preservation of the cast-iron fence, and relaying the original bluestone sidewalks in two ellipses, with renovated lawns, shrubs and flower beds. A few old trees, English elm and Little-leaf linden, still flourish. Further contributions to the park have included Gertrude Vanderbilt Whitney‘s Peter Stuyvesant (1941) and Ivan Mestorvic’s Antonín Dvořák (1963, moved here 1997).

The park is operated and maintained by the New York City Department of Parks and Recreation. The Stuyvesant Park Neighborhood Association works on behalf of park patrons in the surrounding neighborhoods to preserve the park’s historic beauty.

The Cordova family is facing an incredibly difficult time after losing their home in a fire on December 1st. Thankfully, no one was home, and their cat, Nemo, escaped safely. However, everything inside the house was destroyed, leaving them with nothing. They now need help to replace essential items like clothing, shoes, warm coats, personal hygiene products, and prescriptions that were lost.
 
This is a heartbreaking situation, and any support you can offer will make a real difference. Your contribution will go directly toward helping Miriam and Armando as they begin to rebuild their lives. Thank you for considering this.
 
Best regards,

https://gofund.me/709cf4410

PHOTO BY JUDITH BERDY

CREDITS

WIKIPEDIA
JUDITH BERDY

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

12

Friday, December 12, 2025 – THE MAYOR’S HOUSE HAS NOT ALWAYS HOUSED THE MAYORS

By admin

10 ‘secrets’ of Gracie Mansion

Photo by Jim.henderson on Wikimedia

Gracie Mansion, the gracious Federal-style mansion that overlooks the East River from Yorkville’s Carl Schurz Park, has been New York’s Mayoral residence since 1942. But the house had a long history before it started hosting municipal magistrates. Since construction began in 1799, Gracie Mansion has served as a residence, a museum, and even an ice cream stand. As the city prepares to welcome a new mayor to the mansion, here are 10 secrets of the People’s House.

Photo by Limulus on Wikimedia

1. The New York Post was founded on Gracie’s front porch

Archibald Gracie was a prosperous New York merchant who made his money first as an import-export man in the East India Trade, then as a banking executive. He worked and socialized with New York’s elite, counting John Jay as a friend and Alexander Hamilton as a business partner. In 1801, after the Mansion was completed, Gracie hosted a meeting of fellow Federalists. There, Alexander Hamilton recruited investors for The New-York Evening Post (now The New York Post), and Gracie became a partner in the venture.

2. John McComb Jr. might have inadvertently designed both the Mayor’s home and his office

We know for certain who designed the Mayor’s office: Joseph Mangin and John McComb Jr. won the commission to design City Hall in 1802. But nobody can say for sure who designed his house. The Gracie Mansion Conservancy holds that the building was built by Ezra Weeks and was probably designed by McComb, who had already designed Hamilton Grange and St. Mark’s Church in the Bowery and would go on to design other landmarks, including Castle Clinton.

3. Alexander Hamilton died in front of the fireplace now in the Mansion’s ballroom

Following his duel with Aaron Burr in Weehawken, New Jersey, in July 1804, Alexander Hamilton was brought to Bayard House on Jane Street in what’s now the West Village. He died there, in front of the fireplace, on July 12th. That fireplace was installed in Gracie Mansion’s Ballroom in 1966.

4. Gracie Mansion spent nearly 28 years as an ice cream stand

The War of 1812 limited overseas trade and effectively sank Archibald Gracie’s shipping business. To settle debts, Gracie sold the house in 1823. The mansion had a succession of private owners until the city appropriated the estate in 1896 and incorporated its 11 acres into East River State Park, renamed Carl Schurz Park in 1910. As part of the park, Gracie Mansion spent decades as an ice cream stand and public restroom.

5. Gracie Mansion was the first home of the Museum of the City of New York

In 1923, the building was renovated again, going from hawking ice cream to housing artifacts, serving as the first home of the Museum of the City of New York. The Museum continued to use the Mansion until its permanent home was completed on 5th avenue in 1932.

Gracie Mansion in 1936. Photo courtesy of the Library of Congress

6. La Guardia did not want to move into Gracie Mansion

Before Gracie Mansion became the Mayor’s residence on May 26, 1942, New York’s Mayors simply lived in their own apartments. Before he moved, La Guardia was living in an East Harlem tenement. Following Pearl Harbor, Robert Moses decided that it was no longer appropriate.

Powerful New Yorkers had been trying to get La Guardia to move for years. When the industrialist Charles M. Schwab offered to donate his 75-room personal castle on Riverside Drive as the Mayor’s residence, La Guardia scoffed, “What! Me in that?”

But the war made the move particularly prudent. Since New York City was considered a prime target for Nazi bombing squadrons, Moses argued that living on 5th Avenue, at the center of the island, would make La Guardia more susceptible to attack than if he lived on the edge of the island, where he could be more easily evacuated by air or water. Though he did finally agree to move in, La Guardia wrote, “My family is not keen about it, and it has no personal advantage for me.”

7. WNYC had permanent lines installed in Gracie Mansion for direct broadcast

As WWII helped push La Guardia into Gracie Mansion, it also prompted the federal government to order a citywide “dim out” to protect New York from enemy fire. While we can thank that dim out for Brooklyn Blackout Cake, the situation was a dark one for nervous New Yorkers. To reassure his city, La Guardia addressed New York via radio every Sunday. When he moved into Gracie Mansion, WNYC followed suit, setting up permanent lines so the Mayor could broadcast his “Talks to the People” directly from home.

8. The original Yule Log was filmed at Gracie Mansion

Speaking of fire and broadcasting, Gracie Mansion made history on both those fronts. In 1966, WPIX debuted new Christmas programming: The Yule Log. The broadcast was the first of its kind in the world. The footage, 17 seconds of fire blazing merrily in Gracie Mansion’s festively decorated fireplace, played on loop for three hours.

Photo courtesy of the Library of Congress

9. Gracie Mansion’s expansion was controversial for being too traditional

In 1964, Mayor Wagner decided to add a two-story addition to Gracie Mansion so that the home’s public rooms could be separate from the Mayor’s private residence. In an effort to be respectful to the Mansion’s original Federalist style, the Mayor commissioned an addition that would be designed along those same principles. In 1964, in a city that had recently torn down the original Penn Station in favor of the new Madison Square Garden, such historicism proved highly controversial. Modernists were frankly appalled that the new addition would not follow their International Style principles and decried the project.

10. Bloomberg didn’t live in Gracie Mansion, but he did renovate it

Michael Bloomberg was the only Mayor since La Guardia to opt out of Gracie. He chose to remain in his Upper East Side townhouse during his 12 years as Mayor, but paid to give Gracie Mansion a $7 million Federalist facelift. The period-perfect restoration proved much less divisive in 2002 than the addition had been in 1964.

PHOTO BY JUDITH BERDY

CREDITS

Editor’s note: The original version of this article was published on October 24, 2018, and has since been updated.

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

11

Thursday, December 11, 2025 – RESEARCH REVEALS THE TRUTH ABOUT A NEW YORKER

By admin

MANHATTAN’S STATUE TO

UNREPENTANT RACIST

SAMUEL  SULLIVAN COX

Manhattan’s Statue to Unrepentant Racist Samuel Sullivan Cox

December 10, 2025 by Alan J. Singer 

There is a statue of Samuel Sullivan Cox in Manhattan’s Tompkins Square Park. The statue originally was near Cox’s home on East 12th Street but in 1924 it was moved.

A plaque accompanying the statue reads “Samuel Sullivan Cox, the Letter Carrier’s Friend, Erected in Grateful and Loving Memory of his Services in Congress by the Letter Carriers of New York, his Home, and of the United States, his Country.”

While researching a project on slave patrols and the Ku Klux Klan, I came across a quote attributed to S.S. Cox. “When laws become lawless contrivances to defeat the ends of justice, it is not surprising that the people resort to lawless expedients for securing their rights.”

I traced the quote to a book published by Samuel Sullivan Cox in 1885 while a member of Congress representing a district in New York City.

In Union-Disunion-Reunion: Three Decades Of Federal Legislation 1855 To 1885 (Tecumseh, MI: A. W. Mills), Cox argued that post-Civil War Reconstruction was an “unconstitutional exercise of the military power” and the end of Reconstruction “was one good result of the compromises which grew out of the Great Fraud perpetrated by means of the Electoral Commission.”

Cox recognized there were “outrages perpetrated upon the negroes,” but attributed this to the “partial disfranchisement of the whites” and the elevation of “ignorant and brutal negroes” to positions of power in Southern states.

Cox argued “No people, least of all such a proud and intolerant people as that of the South, could see their local governments transferred from their own hands into the hands of their former slaves without being goaded into violent resistance.”

He labeled Reconstruction Acts passed by Congress in the 1860s and 1870s the “chief provocation to Ku-Klux atrocities.”

These were not the first outrageous statements made by Cox. In February 1864, while a Representative from Ohio, Cox warned in a speech to the House of Representatives against emancipation that “millions unfit for freedom are yet to become free” and with freedom “the black will perish.”

Cox believed that in the event of racial mixing, long a practice under slavery in the South as white masters raped enslaved Black women,  “the mulatto does not live; he does not recreate his kind; he is a monster. Such hybrid races, by a law of Providence, scarcely survive beyond one generation.”

While in Congress, Cox voted against the 13th Amendment ending slavery and all three major Reconstruction-era enforcement laws written to protect rights granted to African Americans by the 14th Amendment. Cox was not in office when the 14th and 15th Amendments came up for votes.

The Cox statue was erected on July 4, 1891. It should be removed by July 4, 2026.

Editor’s Note

According to a recent study 99% of statues in American have NOT been removed. Fifty percent of the top 50 most memorialized people in the United States enslaved other people.

In contrast, just 0.5% of recorded monuments nationwide represent enslaved peoples and abolition efforts. Some of these are highlighted in a new book that documents the small number of monuments to Black Americans in New York City.

PHOTO BY JUDITH BERDY

CREDITS

 NEW YORK ALMANACK

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

10

Tuesday, December 9, 2025 – ALL NATURAL MATERIALS REPLICATE STEEL AND CONCRETE

By admin

Guide to the

NYBG Holiday Train Show,

An Annual Love Letter to NYC

New York as Museum City

The five boroughs house 83 museums, with the heaviest concentration on a one-mile stretch of Fifth Avenue on Manhattan’s East Side. The Metropolitan Museum stands at 80th Street, hugging Central Park, from which it has taken substantial property over the years. The NYBG points out that the replica uses cinnamon curls to recall the Met’s Ionic columns.

(Left) Classic New York row houses, some demolished (Right) The elegant National Arts Club is located at 15 Gramercy Park South.

The Frick Collection, a favorite with New Yorkers and especially European tourists, stands ten blocks away from the Met at Fifth Avenue and 70th Street. “The Met is admired, but the Frick is beloved,” says architecture critic Paul Goldberger, comparing New York City’s largest and wealthiest museum with its reserved Fifth Avenue neighbor, which recently reopened after years of renovation.

“Are those mushrooms, daddy?” asked the little boy to my left. Yes, indeed, the Guggenheim has been recreated with shelf fungus. “I think Frank Lloyd Wright would approve,” says Dolan, referring to the Guggenheim’s famously irascible architect. The Guggenheim is both a New York City landmark and a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

The Cooper Union for the Advancement of Science and Art, a private college founded by Peter Cooper in 1859, was tuition-free for most of its history. Its alumnae include renowned architects, engineers, and artists, such as Augustus Saint-Gaudens, Milton Glaser, Lee Krasner, and Thomas Edison. Appropriately enough for the train show, Cooper was an industrialist who designed and built the first American steam locomotive.

Similarly, the replica of Grand Central has columns of sticks, stone walls mimicking limestone, huge rounded windows, and three detailed statues of Hercules, Mercury, and Minerva, representing strength, commerce, and wisdom.

CREDITS

UNTAPPED NEW YORK

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

8

Monday, December 8, 2025 – SOMETIMES BUILDINGS ARE JUST LEFT BETWEE NEW STRUCTURES

By admin

This Tucked-away

Holdout House in East Midtown

was Built 3 Years

Afer the End of the Civil War

This tucked-away holdout house in East Midtown was built 3 years afer the end of the Civil War

All around it are structures you expect to see in the contemporary office enclave west of Lexington Avenue known as East Midtown—imposing facades, lots of glass, buildings that try to make a statement.

When it was completed in 1868, this lovely little survivor was not designed to stand out. It may have been built as an outlier, but it was likely part of a row of identical houses meant to appeal to upper middle class buyers enriched by the city’s gangbusters post-Civil War economy.

The architect, James W. Pirsson (who co-designed the city’s first co-op apartment building on West 57th Street in 1881), created a row of eight Italianate houses with brownstone fronts starting at 113 East 55th Street, according to Andrew S. Dolkart, historic preservationist and author of Central Synagogue in Its Changing Neighborhood.

It’s likely Number 119 was part of that row, which was constructed for a speculative developer. Who would have been the first buyer?

The rapidly developing neighborhood east of Park Avenue attracted business owners and other professionals with large families and several servants, states Dolkart. “Many of the residents were born in Germany, some undoubtably Jewish, reflecting the success of the German immigrant community in New York,” he wrote.

That professional likely commuted to a downtown shop or office via a horse-drawn streetcar, as elevated trains wouldn’t run this far away from the city center until the 1880s.

If they were German Jews, they may have joined the congregation at Central Synagogue, the spectacular Moorish synagogue opened in 1872 around the corner on Lexington Avenue.

With the arrival of mass transit, changes came to East 55th Street. Elite residential areas moved north of 59th Street and commerce came in. Some single-family brownstones were carved into multi-family apartments; others became boarding houses.

Architectural styles changed as well. Assuming it was part of the original row, Number 119 lost its brownstone front and stoop. Are the Greek urns on the window lintels original or a new feature to give the house a Classical edge? The research is scant.

Newspaper archives reveal the names of owners in the 20th century. In 1905, the house was bought by an Abraham Schwab, per the New York Herald.

Mrs. C. Russell Auchincloss resided there with her three children in 1910; she surprised a thief who broke into her bedroom one night to steal her jewelry (he made off with many pieces).

Real estate titan Charles F. Noyes occupied (or at least owned) the house in the 1930s through the 1950s or 1960s. Probably before Noyes moved in, some part of the former home served as the Tree Club, a Prohibition-era speakeasy on a stretch of the city known for its many secret drinking spots.

By the 1940s, 119 East 55th Street looked almost identical to the way it appears today. But it’s still on a townhouse row, flanked on the right by the other survivors of this post-Civil War row.

At some point after the 1940s, the other row houses began to go down. Someone moved the front door at Number 119 to the middle of the ground floor between the windows; the house also gained its rooftop sunroom addition.

Now it’s the last house standing. The story of how it managed to survive in a neighborhood known for its wrecking balls isn’t clear.

But it’s not going down yet. In fact, it’s actually for sale. With an ultra-modern interior (see photos here) its original occupants probably couldn’t even imagine, this historic holdout from New York’s early Gilded Age can be yours for a cool $14 million.

SHAYLA,ARIEL AND MAGGIE  JOINED JUDY BERDY CELEBRATING OUR HOLIDAY WINDOWS.  THE LADIES VOLUNTEERED TO DO A GRAND JOB DECORATING THE RIVERCROSS WINDOWS!

CREDITS

EPHEMERAL NEW YORK

[Fifth image: MCNY; 45.129.36; sixth image: NYC Department of Records & Information Services]

Tags: 119 East 55th Street1860s Rowhouse on East 55th StreetEast 55th Street Row Houses BrownstonesHoldout Buildings from the Civil War in NYCHoldout rowhouse 119 East 55th StreetNew York’s Holdout Brownstones MidtownSpeakeasy Tree Club 119 East 55th Street
Posted in Bars and restaurantsHouses of worshipMidtown

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com

Dec

7

Sunday, December 7, 2025 – ALL NATURAL MATERIALS REPLICATE STEEL AND CONCRETE

By admin

Guide to the

NYBG Holiday Train Show,

An Annual Love Letter to NYC

There’s nothing on the planet quite like the New York Botanical Garden’s Holiday Train Show, which replicates our city’s most treasured buildings, recreating them as botanical masterpieces. Limestone, marble, iron, wood, glass, and steel are replaced with evergreens, twigs, hollies, moss, pine cones, bark, and tree roots. Among and between the nearly 200 buildings, trains chug and glide on 1,200 feet of track, reminding us that New York was once a great train city. And now, in the Bronx, it is once again.

The original genius who created the first train show in 1992—and who invented the term “botanical architecture”—is landscape architect Paul Busse. One of his designers, sculptor Annette Skinner, says that her boss “has a unique concept that requires integration of the natural world with traditional G-scale model railroad layouts.” Founder of the firm Applied Imagination, Busse is a train buff as well as a lover of the forests around his headquarters in Alexandria, Kentucky, 14 miles down the Ohio River from Cincinnati. Those forests provide much of the material to fabricate New York’s skyscrapers and mansions.

Busse’s first building for NYBG was what his daughter, Laura Busse Dolan, calls a “sample:” Poe Cottage. The original cottage, built in 1812, is situated a few blocks away from the Botanical Garden in the Bronx. There Edgar Allan Poe wrote “The Bells,” inspired by the church bells ringing at neighboring Fordham University’s bell tower, and “Annabel Lee,” one of his greatest poems.

  • Paul Busse’s “sample” construction, Poe Cottage, where Edgar Allan Poe lived in the 1840s.

Poe Cottage is far plainer than the magnificent building that Busse replicated next: St. Patrick’s Cathedral in Manhattan. Busse’s botanical St. Pat’s looks remarkably like the real one standing majestically on Fifth Avenue. Designed by James Renwick, Jr., one of the nineteenth century’s finest architects, St. Patrick’s is the largest Neo-Gothic Roman Catholic cathedral in the country. Dolan, who now heads Applied Imagination, says she isn’t sure why her father chose St. Patrick’s as his first major botanical building. But she notes that one huge plus in addition to its fame is its sumptuously decorated facade.

Fifth Avenue’s St. Patrick’s Cathedral was the first major botanical building.

The botanical model of St. Pat’s required three artists working hundreds of hours to complete, using 60 different plant parts overall. Its rose window is composed of eucalyptus pods, pine cone scales, grapevine, poppy seeds, and Siberian iris seed pods.

New York as Train City

The Train Show offers two extraordinary train headquarters: the tragically demolished Penn Station and the still-standing, formidable Grand Central Terminal.Demolished in 1963 by its owner, the Pennsylvania Railroad, Penn Station was spectacular.

Penn Station’s botanical building materials, according to NYBG, include “columns made of honeysuckle, façade trim of sea grape leaves, peppercorns, viburnum, willow, and oak bark, and railings of screw pod, burning bush, willow, and acorn caps. The roof is magnolia, and pine cone scales, and the sky lights are burning bush and basket reed. The adorning eagles have white pine cone bodies, hemlock clove feet, magnolia bud feathers, and acorn cap wings. The clocks are birch bark and wheat seeds, and the statues have pistachio bodies and cedrela wings.”

Similarly, the replica of Grand Central has columns of sticks, stone walls mimicking limestone, huge rounded windows, and three detailed statues of Hercules, Mercury, and Minerva, representing strength, commerce, and wisdom.

MORE IMAGES TOMORROW…

SHAYLA, ARIEL AND MAGGIE  JOINED JUDY BERDY CELEBRATING OUR HOLIDAY WINDOWS.  THE LADIES VOLUNTEERED TO DO A GRAND JOB DECORATING THE RIVERCROSS WINDOWS!

CREDITS

UNTAPPED NEW YORK

All image are copyrighted (c) Roosevelt Island Historical Society unless otherwise indicated
THIS PUBLICATION FUNDED BY DISCRETIONARY FUNDS FROM CITY COUNCIL MEMBER JULIE MENIN & ROOSEVELT ISLAND OPERATING CORPORATION PUBLIC PURPOSE FUNDS.

Copyright © 2025 Roosevelt Island Historical Society, All rights reserved.Our mailing address is:
rooseveltislandhistory@gmail.com